top Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Some questions...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Some questions...

    So I've been reading this forum for awhile now; I hope that I am not reposting ridiculously common questions. I did search for the answers so here goes.

    The background:

    Wife and I have been dealing with debt for awhile. She quit her job over a year ago, just before we had our first child, who ended up in the NICU for the first 2 and a half months of her life (born with one arm, and her liver in the umbilical cord).

    Thankfully we had medical insurance so the losses there were not as epic as they could have been - the total billed to the insurance company was well over half a million, I think - but we still ended up with a fair amount of debt there.

    On top of that, we have something like $40k in credit card debt and a second on our house for another $88k (on top of the first for $244k). The house's worth is up in the air, but we're probably slightly upside down on it at this point, maybe by $15k-$30k.

    I've taken the means test using the washington state form, but I was a little confused by the ownership/lease costs section. (See the form here -end of page 4/top of page 5: http://www.wawb.uscourts.gov/read_fi...file=1378&id=0 ) The amount this allows you to claim as an expense is something like $483 (the form I filled out is at home, so I'm not sure). Does this mean I can claim that as an expense for a car that I own outright?

    If it does, that means I pass the means test - I think we had $41 left over after expenses when I did the official one.

    So. A few questions--

    1. We just went through a situation where we found mold in our kitchen - really bad mold. The dishwasher was leaking, as was the garbage disposal, and we clearly couldn't leave it like that, especially with a kid. Homeowners insurance wouldn't cover it, because it was a seepage issue (and had clearly been going on for some time, as became evident after I tore it apart), so we had to eat the cost. I rebuilt the kitchen - or I'm almost done anyway - on my own to save money, used ikea cabinets (the old ones were rotted), replaced subfloor, drywall, etc. Completely removed everything with even the slightest trace of water damage or mold. Total cost was about $7k, which we largely paid for with credit. I realize that we need to at least put some payments and time in between us and that cost, but we honestly had no choice and we tried to minimize costs at every turn.

    How would something like this be viewed? We have pretty much accepted that we might have to pay this back but obviously if we give up the house - as seems wise, given our situation - that would be something of a bummer.

    2. Is it possible to use the bankruptcy - should we choose to file - as leverage to get our second mortgage to drop their interest rate or forgive some of the debt, or some other favorable arrangement that would make it so it makes sense to keep the house? Since the 2nd is through a different company than the 1st mortgage, I'm thinking that they stand to get basically nothing if the house is foreclosed on, and it might be to their benefit to do something like this. Is this even a consideration?

    3. If we choose to file at some point in the future, what happens to the money we save each month by not paying on the debts? We live on less than what their standard expenses give us to live on - in fact the only absolutely non-essential that we really spend money on regularly is cable/internet - $100/mo -, so we'd probably have some money left over. Especially if we stopped paying on the mortgages in the event we chose to give up the houses - that would be $2700/mo. What is the expectation for this money?

    Alternatively, are we expected to pay on the debts until the BK is completed?

    4. I'm guessing that if we do this, Amex is going to revoke my company credit card (through my employer) since I owe them money on my personal account. Right? I guess it's up to me to decide if the consequences of that from a work standpoint are something I can handle.

    5. I hate this stress so much and just want to find a way to pay it off or declare and be done. I do still harbor some hope that I can make a real payoff happen but it's going to be tough if not impossible, given our situation.

    #2

    I hope the baby is doing well.



    1. We just went through a situation where we found mold in our kitchen - really bad mold. The dishwasher was leaking, as was the garbage disposal, and we clearly couldn't leave it like that, especially with a kid. Homeowners insurance wouldn't cover it, because it was a seepage issue (and had clearly been going on for some time, as became evident after I tore it apart), so we had to eat the cost. I rebuilt the kitchen - or I'm almost done anyway - on my own to save money, used ikea cabinets (the old ones were rotted), replaced subfloor, drywall, etc. Completely removed everything with even the slightest trace of water damage or mold. Total cost was about $7k, which we largely paid for with credit. I realize that we need to at least put some payments and time in between us and that cost, but we honestly had no choice and we tried to minimize costs at every turn.

    If you truly can't pay, then don't. You have to prioratize.


    How would something like this be viewed? We have pretty much accepted that we might have to pay this back but obviously if we give up the house - as seems wise, given our situation - that would be something of a bummer.

    Can you afford to keep the home if all your other debt no longer exsists? If yes, than you don't have to move, if no, then that's the answer


    2. Is it possible to use the bankruptcy - should we choose to file - as leverage to get our second mortgage to drop their interest rate or forgive some of the debt, or some other favorable arrangement that would make it so it makes sense to keep the house? Since the 2nd is through a different company than the 1st mortgage, I'm thinking that they stand to get basically nothing if the house is foreclosed on, and it might be to their benefit to do something like this. Is this even a consideration?

    The only way you can do anything with the second mortgage currently is with a Chapter 13, but your house can be appraised at no more than the current first. If it is, then in a 13 you can try to have the lien stripped.

    Most lenders won't negotiate rate if you're in a BK. I would try now to see if they can help you.


    3. If we choose to file at some point in the future, what happens to the money we save each month by not paying on the debts? We live on less than what their standard expenses give us to live on - in fact the only absolutely non-essential that we really spend money on regularly is cable/internet - $100/mo -, so we'd probably have some money left over. Especially if we stopped paying on the mortgages in the event we chose to give up the houses - that would be $2700/mo. What is the expectation for this money?

    Everything depends on if you are qualified for a 7 or 13. Most people use the money to buy nessecities and do home repairs. Also, the money can be used to retain an attorney.


    Alternatively, are we expected to pay on the debts until the BK is completed?

    Again, it depends on 7 or 13. In any BK, you stop paying your debts that you want to discharge prior to filing to save money.

    4. I'm guessing that if we do this, Amex is going to revoke my company credit card (through my employer) since I owe them money on my personal account. Right? I guess it's up to me to decide if the consequences of that from a work standpoint are something I can handle.

    Not a done deal. I had credit cards personaly and a company card through the same bank, and because my company card was not based on my credit, it was not affected.


    5. I hate this stress so much and just want to find a way to pay it off or declare and be done. I do still harbor some hope that I can make a real payoff happen but it's going to be tough if not impossible, given our situation.

    [COLOR="SeaGreen"]It's a stresfful time indeed. You need to weigh all your options and look at it as impersonaly as possible. Like a corporation would. Your family needs to do what's best for them in the long term. Don't beat yourself up about it...
    Last edited by chloe0724; 11-24-2008, 04:14 PM. Reason: too long
    Filed Chapter 13 05/23/08
    Converted to Chapter 7 Jan 2012
    Discharged April 2012

    Comment


      #3
      Our baby is doing great. 14 months old now and she's just amazing. Her lack of an arm hasn't slowed her down at all, thanks to her fighting spirit. She'll have to have more surgery in the future to finish correcting the stomach thing, but she's healthy for now.

      We could afford to pay for the house, but given the option, if we couldn't reduce what's owed on it, or the interest rates (like... to near 0 on the second) then it would be foolish of us to keep it given that it's upside down.

      At least, that's my take. I love the house, I've put an immense amount of effort into improving it with my own labor, but I'm trying to be as impersonal as possible and just make the right business decision here.

      I'll talk to Countrywide - they are the 2nd holder. My guess is that they aren't going to do much for me but why not try, right? Should I mention the potential for bankruptcy?

      I believe we may qualify for a BK7 but that depends if I'm understanding the means test right. I'll probably end up having to speak with some attorneys to figure this out, but I thought I'd try you folks first as I want to be as informed as possible, and you guys are definitely informative.

      Thank you for your answers thus far.

      Comment


        #4
        one other question --

        I have oft read on these forums that one must come out of a BK worse on paper than when you enter it. can someone clarify this for me?

        clearly if I go in with a negative net worth, the idea is to come out debt free - or as close as possible. even if I gave up everthing, 'on paper' my net worth would increase to zero at least. am I reading too much into this? sorry if this is a dumb question.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by lolasaurus View Post
          one other question --

          I have oft read on these forums that one must come out of a BK worse on paper than when you enter it. can someone clarify this for me?

          clearly if I go in with a negative net worth, the idea is to come out debt free - or as close as possible. even if I gave up everthing, 'on paper' my net worth would increase to zero at least. am I reading too much into this? sorry if this is a dumb question.
          It has nothing to do with net worth. It has to do with being able to file chapter 7. If you show more then $166.00 of disposable income each month you will end up in chapter 13.
          Keep in mind a chapter 7 is going to wipe out ALL dischargeable debt. The means test is only the first part schedule J is where you list all of your allowed actual expresses. That’s where you need to look worse that you did before BK.
          Chapter 7 07/30/2008
          341 09/17/2008
          Discharge 11/21/2008

          Comment


            #6
            I remember before our 341 meeting, our atty sat down and reviewed every little expense and "played with" the numbers to get that magical number. She was really good. A good atty can easily get rid of that $166.
            9/03/08...Chapter 7 Filed
            10/06/08...341 Meeting Done!!! No Objections
            12/08/2008...Case Discharged and Closed!!!

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by RedLight View Post
              I remember before our 341 meeting, our atty sat down and reviewed every little expense and "played with" the numbers to get that magical number. She was really good. A good atty can easily get rid of that $166.
              thats why i say you have to apear worse off after bk then before
              Chapter 7 07/30/2008
              341 09/17/2008
              Discharge 11/21/2008

              Comment


                #8
                Sorry, I don't know why I'm having such a difficult time wrapping my head around this, but...

                Does 'worse' mean I have more or less expenses after BK? Or am I completely misunderstanding what you're saying?

                Comment


                  #9
                  I don't get it either????????????
                  Chapter 7 filed 10/21/2008
                  341 - 11/26 went smooth NO ASSET
                  Took 115 days after 341 - But Finally DISCHARGED 3/25/09

                  Comment


                    #10
                    You have to be able to show that the income you have and the expenses you have at the best case senerio break even without including your debt. That's what people mean when the attorney's play with the numbers.
                    Filed Chapter 13 05/23/08
                    Converted to Chapter 7 Jan 2012
                    Discharged April 2012

                    Comment


                      #11
                      ..............

                      If I make less than my state median amount for my family size, doesn't that supersede the means test?

                      For example, for a family of three in my state, the median income is $54,000. If my family earns $50,000 per year, does it matter if I have $500 extra per month after paying all expenses (the $500 is without current credit card debt)?

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by InDebtNeedHelp View Post
                        If I make less than my state median amount for my family size, doesn't that supersede the means test?

                        For example, for a family of three in my state, the median income is $54,000. If my family earns $50,000 per year, does it matter if I have $500 extra per month after paying all expenses (the $500 is without current credit card debt)?
                        Yes, it can matter. The means test is a shortcut to determine if you can file Ch.7, without presumption of abuse.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          So, the means test is more important than the income threshold? Can you provide a link that explains both issues more completely? Thanks.

                          Originally posted by GreenInkOnPaper View Post
                          Yes, it can matter. The means test is a shortcut to determine if you can file Ch.7, without presumption of abuse.

                          Comment

                          bottom Ad Widget

                          Collapse
                          Working...
                          X