top Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

PLEASE READ THIS POST....Thank You

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    PLEASE READ THIS POST....Thank You

    Thank you in advance for reading my post and offering any and all advice...You guys have been great...

    Ok...My Re-affirmation Problem FILED PRO SE

    October 14: Filed Pro Se Chapter 7
    October 26: Signed Re-affirmation agreement
    December 13: 341 Meeting

    Situation in a nutshell.....A year ago my husband and I went to the bank and put the following collateral up for a business LINE OF CREDIT:

    Pick-up
    Car
    Utility Trailer
    Travel Trailer (which we now use as our home on my husbands job site)

    OK..business obviously failed...and my husband is working back in his trade. We use the Travel trailer (lot rent..electric..free at his job site)

    We decided to re-affirm this loan that has all this collateral wrapped up in it..because we didn't have a place to live...and needed our transportation and we FELT very OBLIGATED to do so...small town bank...everyone knows everyone...and the loan officer is more a friend than our banker.

    HOWEVER: When we brought the re-affirmation papers into the bank and sat down to set up the agreement. Banker raised our interest to 12% with payments for 4 years at 50% of my husbands take home pay each month. WE SIGNED THE AGREEMENT....and were really concerned about being able to make the payment..and told the banker so....He didn't seem to care.

    Anyway...I never filed the Re-affirmation paper with the clerk of the court...nor did the banker ask me to.

    HOWEVER: the trustee asked to have stuff like our checking account statements for 3 months....tax tickets...tax returns...etc to be sent to his office....I also sent along the RE-AFFIRMATION agreement.....figured he'd want to look at it too. BUT I still have not filed it with the clerk....

    The trustee gave us the impression...though he can't advice..but that we should seek legal cousel on this matter. Basically I think he was saying HEY..THIS IS GOING TO PUT YOU IN A BIND...MIGHT NOT WANT TO RE-AFFIRM..but I can't tell you that...seek legal advice...

    MY QUESTIONS OR RATHER MY UNDERSTANDING: It says On the Re-Affirmation agreement that I can CANCEL it at anytime before the case is DISCHARGED...and I do not have to entered into it in the first place....

    OK..if I don't file it with the clerk..I am assuming it never existed...IS THAT CORRECT???..then the debt should get discharged and I can just give the banker who holds the lien the property....or I can pay the OUTRAGEOUS PAYMENTS and if ever I become in default he can take the property, but can't try and collect any money from me...because the debt is discharged.

    I am wondering if I should also probably change my STATEMENT OF INTENT SHEET...to show this as DEBT I am surrending...instead of DEBT I am RE-AFFIRMING.

    Do I have to notify the banker in writing of this change...or just call and ask what he wants done with the property??

    My husband and I have just been realizing how stupid a decision this is to re-affirm...30,000 worth of collateral for a 59,000 loan payment...and the burden the payment makes. We don't want to be in this situation a fews years down the road.

    We can buy a vehicle for what 2 months worth of payements on the re-affirmations would be...and have plenty of MONEY LEFT to rent an APARTMENT...instead of using the travel trailer as a means for a home.

    Should I file an amended DEBTOR'S STATEMENT OF INTENTION?

    Should I also notify bank in WRITING or CALL?

    WHEN YOU CHANGE A SCHEDULE...Do you just submit new schedule to the clerk and tell them it replaces the old one? Or is there a form that must go with it?



    Also, we have already been to our 341 meeting..is it to late to ad a missed creditor to the filing? Not a large sum...just left out by mistake.

    Any advise or help would be GREAT...

    Thank You

    #2
    1. Not too late to add a creditor. That creditor would have an extended deadline for objections, though it wouldn't change the originally listed debts. To amend, you should be able to submit a new creditor schedule-just showing the forgotten debt. You might need to turn in another matrix page. Mark it as 'amended'. Check w/ the clerk to confirm how they want it!

    2. By not submitting the reaffirmation to the court, it isn't valid. Unless the trustee submitted the copy you gave him. Not sure if he can submit it for you. I do understand the trustee has to sign off on a reaffirmation when you're pro se, and can refuse to do so if it presents an extreme financial burden. Even if you had submitted it, you're right that you can cancel it.

    As to what to do next if you've decided to surrender the property, you don't have to contact the lender at all just yet. You are still protected by the automatic stay. That gives you a little time to make other arrangements. As for changing the statement of intentions, its not a bad idea but it may not be an issue. We changed our mind-surrendered what we'd said we would keep. Our trustee wasn't concerned as it didn't change our financial picture.
    Most of my information is from personal experience or HOURS and HOURS of online research. When you're searching online, keep in mind there is no guarantee that the info is completely up to date, and your situation is unique from anyone else's. Do your homework, and consult with an attorney so you can make an informed decision.

    Comment


      #3
      Stacy That was really helpful. Thank You I get such great advice here.

      I was worried and unsure how the Re-Affirmation worked. I too am not sure if the trustee can submit the Re-affirmation for me or not?

      It says on the first page of the Reaffirmation Agreement:

      "You may reseind (cancel) this agreement at any time before the bankruptcy court enters a discharge order or within 60 days after this agreement is filed with the court, whichever is later, by notifying the creditor that the agreement is canceled"


      OK to me that doesn't tell me alot..LOL

      If I had filed it...and then CANCELED it by telling the creditor...then how the HECK would the court no to include it as DISCHARGED and not re-affirmed...

      THAT CONFUSES ME...LOL

      Maybe if I submit the AMENDED Debtors Intention...to show surrendered on this loan...that would work?? I don't know

      Any shed of light here?

      Comment


        #4
        sorry, i used an attorney to make sure everything went right. i can only suggest that you do the same.

        what i can suggest is that no matter what, you had better make super sure that if you do not want to re-affirm after you already signed that you call all parties involved and make sure they know that so that you are all on the same page. also, check with the court and the trusttee to make sure you are not bound by it. you do not want to be locked into something by mistake.

        maybe that means filing an admentment i dont know. but do whatever you have to to make sure you are protected from owning something you thought you wowuldnt.

        good luck
        Im not an attorney or a trustee. You cant trust me either though!

        [x] - Done with 341? Join the 60 Day Club! ___________[x] - Im Discharged! Whoo Hooo!
        [x] - Poll: Should I File Pro-Se ____________________[x] - New BK Law: Median Income, Means Testing and Presumptive Abuse
        [x] - Zombie Debt Collectors Dig Up Your Old Mistakes _-[x] - Bankruptcy Law Resource
        [x] - Need A Fast Answer? Available 24/7!--__________[x] - Dont Be A Hero On Your Budget - You Wont Get An Award!

        Comment


          #5
          Thanks BK

          Yes..I think what I am going to do..is file an amended: DEBTOR'S STATEMENT OF INTENTION...and change the loan from Re-Affirming to .... Surrendering

          I am going to contact the Creditor in person and in writing after I find an apartment and get settled in...say 2 weeks...As Staci said...I am still under the Stay and they can't repo right now anyway.

          What do you guys think?

          It does say on the court papers:

          NOTICE TO DEBTOR:
          You may reseind (cancel) this agreement at anytime before the bankruptcy court enters a discharge order or within 60 days after this agreement is filed with the court, whichever is later, by notifying the creditor that the agreement is canceled.

          Comment


            #6
            'can do', 'want to do' and 'do do' could be all different.

            the problem is getting it done so that the court knows what you want to do.

            thats the part were an attorney comes in for me. so i dont know for sure. as for recinding the re-affirmation i know you can do it before you discharge. just dont know how to do it myself.
            Im not an attorney or a trustee. You cant trust me either though!

            [x] - Done with 341? Join the 60 Day Club! ___________[x] - Im Discharged! Whoo Hooo!
            [x] - Poll: Should I File Pro-Se ____________________[x] - New BK Law: Median Income, Means Testing and Presumptive Abuse
            [x] - Zombie Debt Collectors Dig Up Your Old Mistakes _-[x] - Bankruptcy Law Resource
            [x] - Need A Fast Answer? Available 24/7!--__________[x] - Dont Be A Hero On Your Budget - You Wont Get An Award!

            Comment


              #7
              BK...you crack me up..

              YES..that is exactly correct, BUT I don't know if the Re-Affirmation is even in place...because it says it's not VALID..unless filed with the CLerk of the Court...Which I haven't even done yet....

              My problem with an attorney in the GOD FORSAKEN SMALL TOWN we live in..is there is only 2 BK attorney's within hundreds of miles...

              ALL to busy and have to much of a case load to help within this time frame I'm working with here....

              I NEED A DRINK

              Comment


                #8
                If the re-affirmation agreement hasn't been filed, then all you have to do is contact the creditor and say that you no longer want the terms. BTW, what your "so-dalled friend" offered you was not a re-affirmation, it was a refinance disguised under the term re-affirmation so that the court would accept. A re-affirmation means that they and you agree to continue the original terms of the contract.
                I would suggest that you firs contact the lender and tell them that you will only re-affirm under the original terms of the loan and the original payment amounts. If they will not accept that, you will rescind your offer and include the debt in your Bk. There's no need to wait 2 weeks. If they want to repo, they will have to file for a "relief of stay" and that should give you a month or so.
                IMPORTANT...by contract, you signed that it would be valid, UNLESS you contacted them. This can be done 2 ways. Either you notify them in writing (and I would suggest registered mail-delivery confirmation) or you amend your Bk petition and send them the creditor matrix with them listed and ALSO notify them of your intent to void the agreement.
                My hunch is that if you tell them that you are voiding the agreement unless it is re-written under the original terms of the loan and it will be including in your Bk unless you hear from them within 10 business days (this is why you want to do it now), that you will get a counter-offer from them. Stick to your guns re: the original contract with them. This is certainly no "friend" who would do this kind of thing to you.
                I re-affirmed my car with GMAC at 0% interest and all they did was send me 2copies of the agreement to sign that the original loan/contract/payment length and interest rate were the same.
                Again, what they asked you to agree to is NOT a re-affirmation. If you had an atty, I am sure that they would not advise you to sign it.
                Best wishes, Art

                Comment


                  #9
                  Do you have access to Pacer? That would be a good way to check to see if the page had been filed (such as if the trustee turned it in). The idea to check w/ the clerk to make sure that you do what is needed to cancel it if it has been filed is a good idea.

                  Sounds like you're heading in the right direction... Thinking about the financial future of your family rather than what your banker/friend will think. Good for you!
                  Most of my information is from personal experience or HOURS and HOURS of online research. When you're searching online, keep in mind there is no guarantee that the info is completely up to date, and your situation is unique from anyone else's. Do your homework, and consult with an attorney so you can make an informed decision.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    I think part of the issue is Crazy's loan balance is $59,000 on property that is only worth $30,000. Based on the #'s ($59,000, 4 years, 12%) this would be about $1550/mo. Even at no interest, it would be about $1230/mo.

                    Regardless of terms, not a great deal to reaffirm on.

                    Originally posted by AAAArt
                    My hunch is that if you tell them that you are voiding the agreement unless it is re-written under the original terms of the loan and it will be including in your Bk unless you hear from them within 10 business days (this is why you want to do it now), that you will get a counter-offer from them. Stick to your guns re: the original contract with them. This is certainly no "friend" who would do this kind of thing to you.
                    I re-affirmed my car with GMAC at 0% interest and all they did was send me 2copies of the agreement to sign that the original loan/contract/payment length and interest rate were the same.
                    Again, what they asked you to agree to is NOT a re-affirmation. If you had an atty, I am sure that they would not advise you to sign it.
                    Best wishes, Art
                    Most of my information is from personal experience or HOURS and HOURS of online research. When you're searching online, keep in mind there is no guarantee that the info is completely up to date, and your situation is unique from anyone else's. Do your homework, and consult with an attorney so you can make an informed decision.

                    Comment

                    bottom Ad Widget

                    Collapse
                    Working...
                    X