top Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

CitiFinancial Update

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    CitiFinancial Update

    I received a call on my local CitiFinancial account $6K+ that they had sent my account to the "head office" and they can offer me a new contract at 5-6% interest. This cuts my payments down to a 1/3, given the contractual rate was at 29%.

    I have heard horror stories about Citi, but I have to say when the "fat hit the fire" they finally came to grips with what i could afford in these economic credit condidtions. I'm beginning to think that the major players (Citi, BOFA, Chase, etc) are beginning to see that when folks tell them they absolutely cannot pay a dime, but the debtor has reasonable income, they can offer a reasonable settlement, without taking the large charge-off and write-down of unpaid debt.

    For me, CitiFinancial has been one of my last creditors to realize I am in a debt crisis and either they work with me or they get nothing (or what they can get through selling the debt for perhaps pennies on the dollar.)

    The only player I have left to "deal" with is CapitalOne. The best they have offered is their strange tactic called "hardship." I'm thinking that in the next few months even CapitalOne will have to offer reasonable payment and payoff plans or risk the loss of revenue from selling/charging off debt that could have belonged to them, if they would have worked with the debtor.

    As mentioned elsewhere in the threads here, I would have been on close to a 100% chapter 13 payment plan a 15-18 months ago. As of today, (with the exception of the hard-to-deal-with CapitalOne) my personal negotiations with creditors are a far better deal than what I would have received through a BK 13 ($3500 to attorney, Oregon Trustee gets 10% of overall payment plan, and student loans are forced into deferrment.) Granted, i have no assets or home to protect, but I have found that nearly all creditors are willing ot work with me. I do have to endure my credit being trashed temporarily. I have endured many phone calls from creditors "demanding" money I did not have at the time.

    I doubt that such negotiations with creditors or CA's would have been possible six months ago, but I think the current credit crisis works in the favor of both debtor and creditor. The big national creditors cannot continue to write down the large amounts of debt that they can't collect on. They appear to be more willing to work with debtors than they were 6 months ago. This does make sense since many of these companies were bailed out with loans from foreign banks and investors. These companies also have to pay the interest and debt accrued from the bailout loans from offshore sources. It is in everyone's best interest to work with "those who can pay under new agreements."

    i have stomached a lot these past 12 months, and there is still the possibility that a BK 13 is in my future, but for now, the deals I am getting from creditors far exceed the "deals" I would have received in a BK 13.

    if you are unsure of whether you will gain by BK, my personal advice is: "answer" the phone calls and speak with your creditors or collection agencies, record whatever conversations you have, get familiar with your state laws, etc.

    While experiences will differ among debtors, my experience suggests that speaking with creditors and attempting to negotiaite a new contract is very well within a consumer's ability. If it all goes to hell, there is still a BK 13 as a fall-back. And, th einformation that in the right circumstnaces, one can stall for a very long time and not get suede. In the meantime, I'm finally feeling a bit of relief.

    Stay tuned...

    #2
    I am happy for you. I have been following what you have done for a long time. We will file (hopefully) in April so for us it has become more of a stalling tactic.

    I think you are right that the national creditors cannot continue to write down the large amounts of debt.

    I think the national creditors are in crisis mode. Many of these same lenders were the ones who pushed through BK legislation to slow BK's and force more consumers into 13's. Now they are finding people who will let their house go but continue to pay creditors. (Something I would never do)

    I am waiting for the next lending crisis to hit the fan. Many consumers took out 0 down loans on their homes and insured the first 10-20 perscent with PMI. I am betting the insurance companies do not have the money to pay out on all the forclosures going down. I wonder if the banks will call the insurance companies 10 times a day and demand payment as they do to consumers.
    Filed!!04/23/2008[X] 341 5/27/2008[X]Converted to asset case 5/26/2008 [X]
    DISCHARGE 08/12/2008[X]
    Converted to NO Asset case 12/15/2008[X]
    Closed 12/16/2008 [X]:yahoo::yahoo::yahoo:

    Comment


      #3
      I still do not believe we (the U.S.O or other foreign countries have really began to feel the blow that will probably come from all the credit card debt hanging out there.

      Comment


        #4
        I've been wondering the same thing - my CC are all at 29.999% - how easy is it today to get those rates lowered? One CC (Chase) has a judgment against me - since I have no earned income they haven't been able to get a thing. I do own a home however and do have equity. I do not want to sell if at all possible. When those CC companies ask if you're having probelms making payments - what are they looking for? Most have raised they minimum payments due - and, as I mentioned before, forget those outrageous interest rates!

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by howdidithappen View Post
          I've been wondering the same thing - my CC are all at 29.999% - how easy is it today to get those rates lowered? One CC (Chase) has a judgment against me - since I have no earned income they haven't been able to get a thing. I do own a home however and do have equity. I do not want to sell if at all possible. When those CC companies ask if you're having probelms making payments - what are they looking for? Most have raised they minimum payments due - and, as I mentioned before, forget those outrageous interest rates!
          The name of what you're asking about is a hardship program.

          This is what they seem to look for (in my case at least):

          * Sudden illness that you can recover from. This should explain the lack of income or job loss.
          * Do not ask to be put on the programs. This willl disqualify you from the secret club. :-) Just mention hard times, etc you really really really want to fix your account because you feel so bad about not making payments you are about ready to kill yourself over the guilt.
          * Your account needs to be past due. I found I could not even open negotiations until I was 60 days delinquient on several of my accounts.
          * Collections won't usually offer the programs and might deny they exist. Ask to speak to a supervisor or call your creditors several times at as many numbers / departments as you can find. Do NOT make any payment to collections this will pretty much disqualify you from even getting offered the program...and some will even lie to you just to get a partial payment. You'll need to speak to a manager or someone from a special hardship office will make an appointment to talk with you.
          * Being self employed may have given me an advantage since they can't garnish my wages from an employer.
          * Previously good payment history didn't seem to matter - I had several accounts with payment gaps and had no prob getting onto a program.
          * Mentioning I was going out of town for several months and wanted to wrap up my affiars before leaving seemed to speed up this process.

          Also:

          * Expect your accounts to be closed forevermore...until they call you up again to reopen after a few successful hardship payments. Citi even offered to reopen me at 10% apr after a year of 0% hardship program.

          * Amazon visa (chase I think?) closed me too and threatened to never again give me credit...my hardship was something like 7%? Considering I haven't made a single hardship payment I don't really care.

          Despite all this I am still filing chapter 7, there were 2 banks that didn't work with me - wamu who bought my providian paypal visa, and crap1, so unless all your cards agree to them you're almost better off in bk.

          Comment


            #6
            Intresting... Here is my personal experience.

            Two weeks ago, CitiFianancial agreed to reduce the interest rate from 25% to 8% with a five-year payoff. My payments went from $235 to $115. I had been attempting to pay what I could but fell approximately 90 days behind.

            My citibank CC is a slightly different story, but I'm currently paying on $9K at 0% for 12 months (hardship program,) similar to the last poster.

            I'm not sure that a BK 13 is in my future, but I'm prepared to go there if necessary.

            My biggest current issue is working with CapitalOne. They appear to take a "we won't budge" approach, and I suspect this will eventually go to their "harcore" collection assignees. I'm prepared to answer any lawsuit from them. They will need to sue me in a local district court or local federal court; all of which first require a mediation session with the debot before a lawsuit can commence. I'm guessing they don't want to go there, and we can work out a mutually agreed upon payment and payoff plan. CapOne does not have a tendency to sell their debts to outside collections, but appear to use collection agencies as agents to attempt to collect debt.

            The truth is that if you hope to get any creditor to understand your financial plight, you have to stop paying them for 90 - 120 days. During this time, you will run up interest and late fees.

            I get a few calls now and again, regarding bringing my account "current." These seem to be fishing expeditions, They want to know about my current financial situation, income, etc. I simply tell them I cannot pay, and i am unwilling to share ANY other information with them as this appears to be what brought me (AND THEM) to the current situation.

            Good info by the last poster. Thanks.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by treehugger1 View Post
              I still do not believe we (the U.S.O or other foreign countries have really began to feel the blow that will probably come from all the credit card debt hanging out there.
              I totally agree. The usurious rates the CC companies now charge will come home to roost, and it's not going to be pretty.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by treehugger1 View Post
                Intresting... Here is my personal experience.
                If you've stopped paying credit cards, you've already damaged your credit. Why don't you just file Ch. 7 and not pay anything.

                Is the answer that you wouldn't qualify for Ch. 7, would have to file Ch. 13, and would have to pay more under Ch. 13 than the CC companies are offering?

                Comment


                  #9
                  Rover,

                  I am definitely NOT BK 7 material. I'm BK 13 at 100%. Believe me, I've spoken to many, many attorneys, and they all come up with the same scenario, five-years to pay 100% back ($69K), but the local trustees force all student loans (another $70K) into deferrment for the life of the payback plan. The student loans continue to compund interest, and my loans are very, very old. They have already been consolidated and the best interest I could get was 8.25%. Over five years of forced deferrment, the interest adds another $30 - $35K! Many here have offered advice, and some districts sometimes allow the BK 13 to include student loan payments in plans. Not the case here. I've explained all of this on other posts, but the bottom line is that I need to attempt to work with as many creditors as possible. So far, so good. The other wierd deal here is that the trustee's BK 13 take is 10% here. Add that to the attorney fee of $3k - $3.5K, and I'll come out ahead in the next five years. I do make very good money, and that is what is holding everything together. Currently, any big gain for me would be the automatic stay, but since I am down to only one creditor not working with me and 2K - 3K in collections (somewhere,) I'm going to keep pushing for thiose final negotiations. I doubt that many folks on this site have cases similar to mine, but I post my thoughts and my expereinces. I hope not to offend anyone.

                  Cheers!

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Hardship update:

                    Capital One does have a hardship department but its more like a reduced collections then a negotiation service and is kind of a joke. Even tho I missed the last few hardship payments they wanted to work with me still..as long as I sent money lol.

                    Wamu was the worst...I couldn't negotiate apr or late fees off the account, but if I split the overlimit charge over a 3 month period they were willing to keep the account open. Of course since the account was still overlimit every month it would still get hit with the finance charge fee and then an overlimit fee for that, and then maybe an overlimit fee for the overlimit fee...or something - the representative I talked to assured me they only bill a maximum of 3 overlimit fees per cycle, unless you go under the limit and then over again. LOL

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Penny Less View Post
                      Hardship update:

                      Of course since the account was still overlimit every month it would still get hit with the finance charge fee and then an overlimit fee for that, and then maybe an overlimit fee for the overlimit fee...or something - the representative I talked to assured me they only bill a maximum of 3 overlimit fees per cycle, unless you go under the limit and then over again. LOL
                      That is only about $120 a month in 3 extra fees if they are 39.00 each & what is the min. pay? Like, $130? They love, worship and adore those kinds of payments.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Incredible...One would think that getting their principle amount returned plus some token interest would be beneficial. Logic has no place in credit card debt. BOFA/MBNA, CITI, CitiFinancial, two credit union credit cards, some regional unsecured creditors, etc all eventually came up with a plan. My hats off to these companies for working with my situation. I told all of them if they did not believe I was in a debt crisis, they had my permission to check out my credit reports. All but one of them did. I think when they pulled my credit reports, they said, "HOLY SH*T, this guy's not joking! With the exception of CAPONE, everyone eventually became civil and worked with me. Generally, I cannot even understand the broken English spoken to me by many of the CapOne representatives. I even have amazing recordings now of several conversations where it is apparent the rep cannot even communicate. I'll save them for a judge if the need arises.

                        I have no idea what will eventually go down with CapOne, but either they're insane or they simply don't care (probably both.) I'm writing a proposal and will send it to some Capone vice-president if I can find an address. I will also include all the other written contracts related to my other creditors with my new payment plans. Will they respond? I don't know, but it has to be worth a try. As I've posted elsewhere, in the local courts here, mediation can be requested by a debtor before proceeding with any lawsuit. I get a sense I may get some experience in this. I'll keep you informed.

                        Comment

                        bottom Ad Widget

                        Collapse
                        Working...
                        X